Boston Whaler 17 Montauk vs 190 Montauk
The Boston Whaler 190 Montauk asks $30,500 more at the median ($45,000 against $14,500), measured across 102 listings we track. Below is every difference we can evidence, and the ones we cannot.
Side by side
| Boston Whaler 17 Montauk | Boston Whaler 190 Montauk | |
|---|---|---|
| Median asking priceLower is cheaper to buy, not necessarily better value. | $14,500 | $45,000 |
| Typical low (25th pct) | $9,000 | $38,000 |
| Typical high (75th pct) | $20,500 | $63,500 |
| Length (median listed) | 17.0 ft | 19.0 ft |
| Listings we trackMore listings means an easier boat to find and to resell. | 71 | 31 |
| States with listings | 20 | 13 |
| Engines we see most | Mercury Verado / V8 FourStroke (250–400) | Mercury Verado / V8 FourStroke (250–400) |
| Known problems on file | 0 | 2 |
| Federal recall campaigns (builder) | 13 | 3 |
| Model years traded | 1977–2023 | 2007–2025 |
Method: Both columns come from the same pipeline on the same day, so the comparison is like-for-like. Asking prices, de-duplicated, quartiles rounded to $500.
Sources: BoatVerdict market observations · USCG / CPSC recall records
Which one suits which buyer
Take the Boston Whaler 17 Montauk if…
- Budget is the binding constraint: it asks $30,500 less at the median.
- You want choice: we track 71 of these against 31, so you can afford to walk away from a bad one.
- You would rather not travel: listings in 20 states against 13.
Take the Boston Whaler 190 Montauk if…
- You want the bigger boat: 19.0 ft against 17.0 ft.
- The 170's bigger sibling shares the same near-immune resale: foam-core Whaler cachet plus family-fishing versatility. Clean examples sell in days nationwide.
Every line above is derived from a number in the table, not from an opinion about the brands. What we cannot tell you from listing data is how they ride, how they are built, or which dealer network is better near you — so we do not pretend to.
Looking at a Boston Whaler 17 Montauk for sale?
Paste the listing and we will score that specific boat against everything on this page: asking price versus our observed range, engine and hours risk, the known issues for its model year, and a negotiation position. The verdict is free.
Get the free verdict →No account needed. The paid Deal Report is optional and comes after.